WILL THE COURTS PUNISH A LITIGANT FOR THE MISTAKE OR NEGLIGENCE OF COUNSEL?

CASE STUDY

FBN V. OBOH (2026) 16 NWLR (PT 2065) 251


FACTS

In the instant case, the 1st and 2nd Respondents were judgement creditors against the 3rd and 4th Respondents. The Supreme Court had on the 28th of January, 2022 made a Garnishee Order Absolute against the Appellant and the 4th Respondent on account of the judgment debt.
Subsequently, the appellant filed an application at the trial court which held that it lacked the requisite jurisdiction to hear the application. The latter, therefore, dismissed the application as an abuse of court process. The Appellant/Applicant then further appealed to the Court of Appeal but failed to file its brief of argument. The 1st and 2nd Respondents in response, applied for the dismissal of the appeal via a motion on notice. Still, the Applicant failed to file its brief of argument neither did it apply for extension of time to file one. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on the basis of its failure to file a brief of argument.
Still dissatisfied, the Applicant appealed to the Supreme Court.

DECISION

On whether the court will punish a litigant for the mistake or negligence of counsel, the Supreme Court held that the courts will normally not punish a litigant for the mistake or negligence of his counsel. However, the court must first be satisfied that the allegation of counsel’s error is true and genuine and also that it serious enough to destroy their case. Thus, the courts must make a clear distinction between procedural irregularities and error in the conduct of a case.
Where there are minor procedural irregularities, the courts would normally ignore them. Where, however, there is a fundamental error in the manner of counselling prosecution of the case, the litigant is bound. Hence, once a litigant chooses a counsel, he is bound to accept his professionalism or lack of it.
The maxim caveat client (let the client beware) of the competence of counsel is normally applicable where the conduct of the case was fundamentally lacking in diligence and excellence. Similarly, when the client is complicit in counsel’s negligence or indolence, the courts will penalize accordingly.

Loading